Sell Your Coin Collection to a Real Expert
Fair prices based on current auction results, shown to you upfront. No pawn-store lowballs. Cash or check paid today.
☎ 973-378-1690
Call or text a photo for a free estimate
Run by Matthew, a published numismatic author and specialist in US, world, and Central American coinage. Member of the ANA with 15+ years of experience.
We buy all types
✓ US coins, colonial through modern
✓ Foreign and world coins
✓ Gold and silver bullion
✓ Paper money and banknotes
✓ Inherited and estate collections
✓ Any size, any condition
What our clients say
★★★★★
"He was extremely helpful in selling a modest US coin collection I inherited. His prices were fair and his enthusiasm evident. I highly recommend Madison Rare Coins!"
Eric W., Brooklyn, NY
★★★★★
"I inherited a large coin collection from my grandfather and shopped around for a few quotes. This was the only place that took me through what the coins were worth before making an offer so I felt more confident and taken care of. They kept the collection together and brokered a sale with a local collector."
Allison O., NJ
★★★★★
"Matt was very honest, transparent and trustworthy. He not only offered a fair price for some of my items but also provided me an education in the market and potential future values of certain items. I will definitely do business with Matt again."
William C., Califon, NJ
Common questions about selling coins
Where can I sell coins in Morris County NJ?
Madison Rare Coins in Mendham, NJ buys coin collections across Morris County. We drive to you in Morristown, Chatham, Basking Ridge, Parsippany, and surrounding towns. Call 973-378-1690 for a free estimate.
How do I sell an inherited coin collection?
Call a reputable coin dealer who will walk you through the collection and explain what each coin is worth before making an offer. Avoid pawn shops and cash-for-gold operations. Madison Rare Coins specializes in inherited collections and bases all offers on recent auction results, shown to you upfront.
How much are my old coins worth?
Coin values depend on date, mintmark, condition, and current market demand. A professional numismatist can identify key dates and varieties that are easy to miss. Text a photo to 973-378-1690 for a free estimate.
Should I clean my coins before selling them?
No. Cleaning coins almost always reduces their value. Original toning and patina are highly sought after by collectors. Leave coins as they are and let a professional evaluate them.
Do you buy foreign and world coins?
Yes. Madison Rare Coins buys US, foreign, and world coins of all types. We specialize in Latin American and Central American coinage, Mexican 8 Reales, German States Thalers, Chinese silver dollars, and more.
Ready to find out what your coins are worth?
Call or text us a photo. We usually respond within the hour.
☎ 973-378-1690
13 West Main St, Mendham, NJ 07945
By appointment. We are often on the road visiting collections.